You Are What You Do by Daniel Im–Book Review

This book by Daniel Im, is organized around seven lies that are pervasive in our culture:

  • You are what you do
  • You are what you experience
  • You are who you know
  • You are what you own
  • You are who you raise
  • You are your past

It is chock full of interesting and surprising facts to support how technology is influencing us and accelerating change (not always good) in modern society. Although I agree with his assertions, many of the topics included are not supportive of his premise, or seem completely extraneous.  For example he speaks about the “gig economy” as a way that people think “I am what I do.”  In the gig economy an individual pieces together multiple jobs and roles to earn a living.  A more appropriate illustration, in my mind, is the person who is completely focused on climbing the corporate ladder in a single vocation, becoming a workaholic or falling into despair when he or she fails to succeed or loses that identity.  Under the heading, “I am what I know” Im tells us that when education became mandatory in 1918, the goal of the system was to produce compliant factory workers — people who would conform to routine and be obedient.  If that’s the case, does it really cause students to think the more education I get, the better off I’ll be?  I don’t think so.  Therefore this information is interesting but not particularly pertinent.

Some biblical references were brought into the mix, but they seemed tacked on rather than woven into the discussion.

Pieces of the author’s personal story were given, but never fleshed out.  I would have been interested to hear more.

Im also mentions many things I had never even heard of:

  • Digital hoarding
  • Viber messaging app
  • Deciding to vacation based on how “instagramable” the location is
  • A game called “Go”
  • Preschool youtubers

This book may resonate with millennials, but it didn’t work well for me.  Possibly the culture has drifted so far from my worldview that I no longer understand it.

VERDICT:  Two stars.  Although there was nothing wrong with the ideas presented,  I found it fragmented and unsatisfying.

If you would like to purchase this book follow the link below:

https://www.lifeway.com/en/product/you-are-what-you-do-P005812198

The Lutheran Ladies received a free copy of this book in return for a fair and honest review. Disclaimer pursuant to FTC 16 CFR Part 255

 

 

 

Same or Different?

This post was written by Lynn Wellumsom, our national WMF(Women’s Missionary Federation) president and published in the Fall edition of the Helping Hand Newsletter.  I thought it spoke to our monthly theme of Reformation, and received her permission to share it on the Lutheran Ladies Connection blog.  For more information on the Women’s Missionary Federation, click on WMF on our header.

Katie Von Bora Luther entered a convent around the age of five.  She used a slate and chalk, my darling six-year old Naomi entered Riverside Christian School with an ipad.  Virtually the same size.  Same or different?

Katie met, got acquainted and married Martin Luther through difficult and dangerous circumstances.  Today people go to On-Line dating services and search for a perfect mate.  Same or different?

Katie and Luther, as married adults, lived in tumultuous times.  Today our nation is going through cataclysmic changes.  Same or different?

Martin Luther nailed the 95 thesis to the church door, the bulletin board of its day.  Anyone can post on Facebook today.  Same or different?

Martin translated the Bible from original languages.  Wycliffe Bible translators, in some cases, can speak a language into a computer that translates into another language.  Same or different?

The biblical theology Luther discovered was quickly disseminated through pamphlets and books using Guttenberg’s new invention, the printing press.  Kindle makes it possible to access millions of books in electronic form almost instantly, less trees die.  Same or different?

Times and methods may change but the message remains:  Jesus Christ is the same yesterday, today and forever.